Whose Terms? — See how power works

Under the Map — How an Occupation Becomes a System

Sources and reading paths

These cards accompany the actual scenes. A working link does not validate every interpretation; use the stated locator, date, supported claim and limits. An external page may move or change after review.

icj_2024 · Advisory opinion

ICJ advisory opinion on the occupied Palestinian territory, 19 July 2024

International Court of Justice; official United Nations transmission A/78/968 · Opinion 19 July 2024; UN transmission 24 July 2024

Open original source

The Court found Israel’s settlement regime in the West Bank and East Jerusalem unlawful, and its continued presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory unlawful. It identified duties to end that presence, halt new settlement activity and make reparation. Gaza withdrawal did not fully end occupation-law obligations, which remained tied to effective control. Oslo did not displace applicable international-law obligations.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Paragraphs 78–83 (scope), 94 (Gaza), 102 (Oslo), 155 (settlements), 205 (movement), 261–264 and 285 (continued presence and obligations).

Access note: Full 85-page official UN Documents copy retrieved; cited paragraphs inspected. Direct ICJ and UNISPal routes returned access errors.

Five minutes: Compare the policy finding in paragraph 155 with the continued-presence finding in paragraphs 261 and 285.

Fifteen minutes: Compare paragraphs 102 and 205 with a particular restriction: distinguish a stated reason, relevant evidence and a legal justification.

abu_awwad · Case record

The Abu Awwad family’s access petition and implemented remedy

Yesh Din, representing the family · Page published 1 August 2024; subsequently updated

Open original source

The farming family challenged restrictions on vehicles, services and farmland around its Turmusaya home. Yesh Din reports that a site visit undermined the army’s claimed alternative route. In late December 2024, a gate replaced the earth roadblock and the family received a key. The subsequent judgment is a separate event.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: HCJ 4239/24; household account; 9 December hearing; 15 December site visit; late-December implementation; February 2025 disposition.

Access note: Full updated account inspected. Direct text retrieved in the 26 October audit. Linked original legal documents require their own intake.

Five minutes: Compare the army’s alternative-route assertion with the reported site finding. Which question does each address?

Fifteen minutes: Follow the family’s demand, correspondence, petition, response, hearing and gate/key implementation. Identify what changed and what this case cannot establish.

dweikat · Judgment

Dweikat v. Government of Israel: the Elon Moreh land case

Supreme Court of Israel; English translation hosted by Cardozo VERSA · 1979; date conflict in the English record

Open original source

Palestinian landowners obtained relief against the particular military seizure on their plots. The court examined competing security evidence and the settlement’s stated purpose. This constrained that seizure; it did not decide the legality of every settlement or prove every later land-policy change.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Actual judgment, concluding order: possession order 16/79 invalidated for the petitioners’ registered plots; no road-land relief under order 17/79 because these petitioners held no title there. Separate the editorial abstract from the judgment.

Access note: Full English record inspected. The editorial abstract is expressly separate from the judicial text.

Five minutes: Find the actual order for relief. Which land and order did it concern?

Fifteen minutes: Compare the affidavits, judgment and editorial abstract. Test claims about this seizure separately from claims about all settlements or later policy.

homesh · Case record

Burqa landowners, Homesh and the gap between title and access

Yesh Din · Updated petition chronology

Open original source

The settlement’s 2005 evacuation did not itself restore Palestinian entry to these privately owned plots. The account describes a military seizure order, its revocation in 2013, continuing practical obstruction and later legal/political changes. Repealing an Israeli entry ban did not convert Palestinian private property into Israeli ownership.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Post-2005 seizure order; HCJ 9389/11; later hearings; 21 March and May 2023 updates.

Access note: Full updated primary litigation account inspected and directly retrieved.

Five minutes: Separate the 2005 evacuation from the 2013 legal change. What did each change?

Fifteen minutes: Trace title, entry rules, unauthorized presence and the March/May 2023 changes as separate layers.

withdrawal2005 · Contemporaneous record

What changed during the 2005 disengagement?

UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) · 12 September 2005; companion report 23 August 2005

Open original source

OCHA recorded free traffic at Gaza’s Abu Houli junction and access to former enclaves after checkpoints and fences were dismantled. Some roads still needed repairs; external crossings had distinct conditions. The separate August northern West Bank report records evacuations alongside continued restrictions, not a general reopening.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Gaza report section 3, Internal movements and closure; compare section 2, External movements. Northern West Bank report sections 1, 4 and 5.

Access note: Both original PDFs acquired and text inspected.

Five minutes: Compare one connection already open with one awaiting repair. Why do they need different map states?

Fifteen minutes: Compare internal movement, external crossings and the northern West Bank report. Identify the gain, its place/date and limit.

order2195 · Official instrument

Military Order 2195 and the power to delegate

Israeli military commander; source page and analysis by Peace Now · 2024; source page 21 June 2024

Open original source

The signed amendment enables the Civil Administration head to delegate specified powers to a civilian-affairs deputy and changes related legal-advice arrangements. Legal permission to delegate is different from an evidenced delegation and a later implemented decision.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Signed Order 2195 amending Order 947, inserted section 5A. The separate appointment scan is marked draft.

Access note: Signed four-page Hebrew instrument acquired and inspected; interpretation page directly retrieved.

Five minutes: Identify the power the order permits. What additional record would establish its use?

Fifteen minutes: Compare the signed instrument, draft status and later implementation evidence without collapsing them into one event.

ocha_access · Data

Movement and Access in the West Bank, April 2026

OCHA · 23 April 2026

Open original source

The inventory records 925 movement obstacles across the West Bank, including East Jerusalem: 89 continuously staffed checkpoints, 218 partial checkpoints, 232 road gates, 114 linear closures, 167 earthmounds and 105 roadblocks. The total is not a count of continuously staffed checkpoints.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Key facts, obstacle categories, observation date and footnotes.

Access note: Full primary fact sheet and companion-map landing page inspected. The large poster PDF is linked by OCHA but was not visually inspected or treated as GIS.

Five minutes: Make a claim the six categories support. Which noun belongs after 925?

Fifteen minutes: Inspect footnotes and compare dates, categories and scope. Ask what further data a particular journey requires.

hdx_access · Data

Historical humanitarian-access geometry

OCHA, distributed through HDX · Metadata checked 26 October 2026

Open original source

The acquired access geodatabase is historical. Its metadata range ends in June 2022. It can support a dated historical layer; it cannot locate the December 2025 inventory by simply changing a label.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Dataset temporal metadata and resource closures_2022.gdb.zip.

Access note: Metadata and original geodatabase ZIP acquired; data scope inspected.

Five minutes: Which date belongs on this layer?

Fifteen minutes: Compare its coverage with the newer fact-sheet total. List the data needed for a defensible update.

cod_admin · Data

State of Palestine common administrative boundaries

Palestinian Authority Ministry of Planning; OCHA/HDX COD publication · Metadata checked 26 October 2026

Open original source

These administrative outlines can orient a regional view. ADM1 contains the West Bank and Gaza regions; ADM2 contains sixteen governorates. These are not private-property, locality-census, Area A/B/C or settlement-jurisdiction polygons.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Acquired GeoJSON archive: ADM1 has two regions; ADM2 has sixteen governorates; explicit coordinate reference information.

Access note: Metadata and GeoJSON archive acquired and structurally inspected.

Five minutes: Which geographical unit does this layer contain?

Fifteen minutes: Compare an administrative outline with the boundary or property data a proposed calculation needs.

peacenow_population · Data

Settlement population, sites and authorization records

Peace Now, Settlements Watch · Mutable public workbook; snapshot acquired 26 October 2026

Open original source

The workbook distinguishes sites, establishment, population and authorization stages. Some coordinate columns labeled UTM contain apparent degree values. Raw labels are preserved; axes and datum need validation before exact spatial calculations.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Acquired workbook: Outposts, Settlements and Outpost Legalization tabs; original headers and row dates.

Access note: Landing page and workbook acquired; tabs, headers and selected rows inspected. Snapshot checksum retained in the research record.

Five minutes: Find a field that changes legal status rather than physical presence.

Fifteen minutes: Compare population, site history and authorization records; inspect missing values and the coordinate problem.

peacenow_lands · Data

Land declarations: event records and their limits

Peace Now, Settlements Watch · Landing-page label December 2024; acquired sheet includes later rows

Open original source

This table records declaration events and reported areas. Its landing-page date does not describe every current row. Declarations are not an authoritative private-ownership map, and overlapping events cannot simply be added as unique territory.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Linked workbook: Date, Year, Dunams, Acres, Description, Village and Remarks.

Access note: Landing page and workbook acquired; original fields and row dates inspected.

Five minutes: Which date is the observation: the page or the row?

Fifteen minutes: Inspect definitions and possible overlap before proposing a total-area chart.

yeshdin_files · Data

Law enforcement on Israeli civilians: monitored investigation files, 2005–2025

Yesh Din · 1 January 2026

Open original source

Of 1,750 monitored investigations, 1,685 were concluded and 65 pending. Six closed files reopened and led to indictments. Treat appeals as transitions rather than forcing 1,578 closure histories and 113 indictment histories into a disjoint pie.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Monitored population; concluded/pending counts; closure/indictment histories; reopening notes and failure denominator.

Access note: Primary page and linked Hebrew data sheet acquired and inspected.

Five minutes: Why do the outcome histories overlap?

Fifteen minutes: Follow an appeal/reopening transition and inspect the denominator and exclusions.

berda · Academic argument

The Permit Regime: Bureaucracy as a Weapon

Yael Berda · August 2020

Open original source

Berda explains how categories, documents and permission shape ordinary movement and planning. The essay directs attention to institutional work behind an encounter rather than explaining the system only through a visible checkpoint.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Public essay on classification, permission, administrative uncertainty and mobility.

Access note: Full public essay inspected and directly retrieved.

Five minutes: Follow one administrative decision into an ordinary goal.

Fifteen minutes: Distinguish the stated rule, actual practice and the author’s explanation.

hammami · Academic argument

Destabilizing Mastery and the Machine

Rema Hammami · Online 29 October 2018; Current Anthropology 60(S19), 2019

Open original source

Hammami foregrounds Palestinian interpretation, embodied interaction and agency. Formal categories do not make a checkpoint a seamless machine. A diagram should expose what a rule can explain and what lived practice requires it to qualify.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Abstract; The Sorting Function; The Repulsions of Homophily; method notes 2 and 4; pp. S87–S97.

Access note: Full free journal text inspected through research retrieval; direct downloader returned an access error in the audit.

Five minutes: Which actual practice would a clean rule diagram miss?

Fifteen minutes: Compare a formal sorting category with the author’s Palestinian-centered account.

farsakh · Academic argument

Rethinking Statehood in Palestine

Leila H. Farsakh, editor, with distinct chapter authors · 2021

Open original source

The edited book asks how statehood relates to self-determination, rights and political community. Its distinct authors make a West Bank resident map an insufficient definition of every person or claim an arrangement must address.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Introduction pp. 12–16; contents locate Baconi on Gaza, Akram on nationality, Masri on constitutions and Nassar on Palestinian citizens of Israel.

Access note: Complete open-access publisher PDF acquired; selected sections inspected.

Five minutes: Read pp. 12–13. Distinguish creating a state from securing self-determination.

Fifteen minutes: Read pp. 12–16 and locate a chapter relevant to a constituency missing from the map.

yiftachel · Academic argument

Deepening apartheid

Oren Yiftachel · 2023

Open original source

Yiftachel offers an attributed analysis of spatial power. Use a particular planning, allocation or authority mechanism to test the argument; do not treat a regime label as a substitute for evidence.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Framework and dated account of changing territorial/political arrangements.

Access note: Full journal text retrieved and relevant argument inspected.

Five minutes: Choose one mechanism and the evidence it requires.

Fifteen minutes: Compare a dated instrument with the explanation and one rival account.

peled · Academic argument

Being Israeli: Dynamics of Multiple Citizenship — introduction

Gershon Shafir and Yoav Peled · 2002

Open original source

The authors analyze citizenship, national membership and differentiated incorporation, including changing projects and hierarchies. Formal citizenship, practical entitlement and resource access are related but distinct.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Publisher’s actual introduction/excerpt; not the full book.

Access note: Publisher excerpt acquired and inspected.

Five minutes: Separate membership, legal right and practical access.

Fifteen minutes: Reconstruct the mechanism before testing which later evidence it explains.

yunus · Judgment

Ali Yunis v. Minister of Finance, HCJ 5/54

Original judgment; translation and scan record through the Nakba Files · 1954 litigation

Open original source

This case distinguishes a Palestinian citizen’s land dispute from the later military-authority chain governing occupied noncitizens. Citizenship did not itself settle possession, expropriation or compensation.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Translated judgment and original-scan record; possession, ministerial certificate and compensation chain.

Access note: Translated judgment and original-scan record inspected.

Five minutes: Which institution decides which question?

Fifteen minutes: Compare this chain with the West Bank household case: identify continuity and legal discontinuity.

gisha_students · Case record

Students seeking permission to study in the West Bank

Gisha · September 2012

Open original source

The education case separates studying, permission to travel and permission to be present in the West Bank. Another physical route does not by itself answer the latter questions.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Student-case publication: purpose, official categories, separation rationale and petition outcome.

Access note: Publication inspected through research retrieval; direct download returned an access error. The bundled account is bounded to that record.

Five minutes: Separate the destination from the permissions needed to study.

Fifteen minutes: Compare educational demand, official category and reported legal result.

alhaq_accountability · Monitoring report

Semi-annual field report on human rights violations, 2021

Al-Haq · 25 August 2021

Open original source

Al-Haq distinguishes responsibilities of authorities with different powers. Palestinian institutions’ own conduct remains accountable, without equating their powers with those of the occupying authority or erasing external constraints.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Separate Israeli, Palestinian Authority and Gaza de facto authority sections.

Access note: Full primary report page retrieved and inspected.

Five minutes: Which institution had responsibility for this action?

Fifteen minutes: Compare each authority’s powers and the report’s evidence.

karzaliyah · Photographic record

Ein Karzaliyah: household life and demolition, 2013–2014

B’Tselem; photographs by Atef Abu a-Rub · Photo essay 8 January 2014

Open original source

The historical series shows an Ein Karzaliyah resident and community before demolition, machinery and military vehicles, and residents afterward. It supports inquiry into household dependencies and a recorded material consequence.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Photo essay and individual image records; separate before/after dates.

Access note: Indexed account and three individual image records checked; direct B’Tselem request was rate-limited.

Five minutes: What does the caption establish that the picture alone leaves unknown?

Fifteen minutes: Inspect dated originals and the relevant authority/material relationship.

road4370 · Dated spatial account

Road 4370: a source-locked January 2019 access comparison

FMEP settlement report; related Ir Amim analysis · 11 January 2019; Ir Amim report January 2020

Open original source

The report distinguishes a Jerusalem-connected route for Israeli-approved traffic, including Palestinians with Israeli-issued permits, from a sealed route between West Bank areas without Jerusalem access. The comparison concerns dated status and authorization, not appearance alone.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Eastern Ring Road/Route 4370 section; Ir Amim report p. 9.

Access note: Contemporaneous text inspected and directly retrieved. Related Ir Amim PDF direct request was blocked.

Five minutes: Hold the destination constant. Which condition changes the reachable network?

Fifteen minutes: Compare transport connection, territorial authority and development space.

bus2015 · Dated policy account

The 2015 bus-separation pilot and its freeze

B’Tselem · 20 May 2015

Open original source

The statement concerns a specific proposed arrangement that was frozen: a bounded example of a policy contested and stopped, alongside the organization’s account of prospective harms.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Statement on the separation pilot and its freezing.

Access note: Indexed primary text inspected; direct request rate-limited.

Five minutes: Was the measure proposed, implemented or frozen?

Fifteen minutes: Compare evidence for intention, operation and reversal.

teacher · Palestinian-authored account

A Palestinian teacher on sustaining education in Masafer Yatta

Awdah Hathaleen · 15 November 2022

Open original source

Hathaleen writes about keeping education possible in Masafer Yatta. Begin with the educational project and professional work, then inspect the specific institutional and movement conditions.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Opening account, named teachers’ journeys and separately dated captions.

Access note: Full article and captions inspected and directly retrieved. Image rights remain separate.

Five minutes: What are the teachers sustaining beyond reaching a destination?

Fifteen minutes: Compare one attributed account with its governing condition and distinct photograph dates.

tamimi · Non-graphic case record

Muhammad Tamimi: a child’s death and the reported inquiry

B’Tselem; companion Palestinian Centre for Human Rights account · June–July 2023 accounts

Open original source

Muhammad Tamimi was two and a half when he was shot and later died. A detailed branch states his death before entry and distinguishes the family’s account, recorded event and official inquiry. The learner cannot change his survival.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Identity, chronology, family account and described military inquiry.

Access note: Indexed B’Tselem account inspected; direct request rate-limited. PCHR text directly retrieved.

Five minutes: Separate event, attribution and inquiry from disputed questions.

Fifteen minutes: Compare accounts and preserve material discrepancies rather than inventing a resolution.

duma · Non-graphic case record

Duma: arson, bereavement and accountability

B’Tselem; Israeli court records for later proceedings · Attack 2015; trial 2020; appeal record 2022

Open original source

The arson attack killed Ali Dawabsheh and later his parents. A subsequent Israeli murder conviction is essential to its history. Prevention, prosecution, conviction, appeal and material remedy answer different questions.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Initial attack account; Central District Court 932-01-16; Criminal Appeal 7388/20.

Access note: Initial account inspected through research retrieval; direct rate limit. A 2022 appeal copy was acquired; do not invent later developments.

Five minutes: Which evidence addresses prevention, prosecution or remedy?

Fifteen minutes: Compare attack, trial and appeal records with separate dates and source types.

zanuta · Palestinian-authored account

After expulsion, a precarious return to Zanuta

Hamdan Ballal Al-Huraini, +972 Magazine · 9 September 2024

Open original source

Residents returned and resumed activities after a reported court decision. The author also records precarious protection and an initial return of men and boys while women and children had not safely returned. Order, return and ability to remain differ.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Chronology; resident accounts; grazing, fruit, tea, homes; household participation limits.

Access note: Full text and captions inspected and directly retrieved. A link does not clear photograph reproduction.

Five minutes: Narrow community returned to what the account establishes.

Fifteen minutes: Trace action, advocacy, return and protection, then compare the later Amnesty update.

amnesty_zanuta · Monitoring / urgent action

Zanuta: a later protection and displacement update

Amnesty International · July 2026

Open original source

This later record prevents a 2024 return becoming an undated ending. Distinguish Amnesty’s monitoring/advocacy account and demands, the court order and observed compliance.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Two-page Urgent Action, MDE 15/1320/2026.

Access note: Complete two-page primary PDF acquired and inspected.

Five minutes: What must the later date qualify in the 2024 account?

Fifteen minutes: Compare order, return, protection and durable residence across dated sources.

norway2024 · Official account

A temporary clearance-revenue arrangement and actual transfer

Government of Norway · 29 February 2024

Open original source

Norway reported a temporary arrangement that triggered a NIS 407 million transfer to the Palestinian Authority. A transfer, dependable revenue and a functioning local service are different findings.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: NIS 407 million transfer; Norway’s intermediary role and the disputed share.

Access note: Full official release inspected and directly retrieved.

Five minutes: Which financial step did this arrangement achieve?

Fifteen minutes: Follow collection, transfer, dispute, payroll and service dependencies separately.

worldbank2026 · Economic data / analysis

Economic Update on the West Bank and Gaza, May 2026

World Bank · May 2026

Open original source

Clearance revenues are mainly VAT and import duties collected by Israel and due for monthly transfer to the PA under the Paris Protocol. The report describes those transfers as fully suspended since May 2025, within its end-April 2026 cutoff. This limits what the 2024 workaround establishes about a later service test.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Cutoff note and fiscal discussion of revenues, salary/arrears and banking pressures.

Access note: Complete primary PDF acquired; cutoff, fiscal discussion and footnote 12 on printed page 8 inspected.

Five minutes: Separate observation and publication dates.

Fifteen minutes: Compare the fiscal account with the 2024 workaround and identify which proposed change affects which dependency.

cmwu · Palestinian institutional account

Who operates and maintains Gaza’s water services?

Coastal Municipalities Water Utility (CMWU) · Undated institutional page, checked 26 October 2026

Open original source

CMWU names Palestinian technical, engineering, operational, procurement, financial and oversight responsibilities. The institution is an agent, but its chart does not establish control of every input or normal operation under current conditions.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Leadership/oversight; operations/maintenance; engineering/planning; administrative/financial sectors.

Access note: English page inspected and directly retrieved; linked Arabic institutional name verified on 26 October 2026.

Five minutes: Which task belongs to the local operator and which input lies outside it?

Fifteen minutes: Follow a hypothetical repair through operations, procurement, funding, entry and oversight.

ocha_gaza2026 · Dated operational record

Humanitarian Situation Report, 15 October 2026

OCHA · Published 19 October 2026

Open original source

The account describes continuing civilian harm and constraints on essential services, including shortages affecting health and water. It supplies dated conditions against which a hypothetical repair or access provision can be tested.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Gaza period note, service constraints and access/coordination accounts.

Access note: Full report directly retrieved; relevant sections and period inspected.

Five minutes: What input could stop a service after a passage right is specified?

Fifteen minutes: Separate authorization, physical availability, operation and resources.

benvenisti · Attributed argument

The Inevitable Bi-national Regime

Meron Benvenisti; translated by Zalman Amit and Daphna Levitt · 22 January 2010 posting

Open original source

The page identifies a translated Hebrew Haaretz extract. Benvenisti argues that entrenched legal, infrastructural and political control matters beyond settlement buildings and divides Palestinians into differently governed constituencies. The game tests the diagnosis, not an answer key.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Author extract after the editorial introduction; translation/provenance note.

Access note: Translated extract and provenance note inspected and directly retrieved.

Five minutes: Separate settlement counts from an apparatus-of-control claim.

Fifteen minutes: Name evidence that would weaken the claim and evidence that would change only part of it.

geneva_accord · Proposed arrangement

The Geneva Initiative: Draft Permanent Status Agreement

Geneva Initiative; copy hosted by Economic Cooperation Foundation · Document dated 12 October 2003

Open original source

The draft includes a proposed Gaza–West Bank corridor, guarantees, disputes and refugee arrangements. Inspect the text before treating a map’s silence as an absent provision. These are commitments to test, not an enacted transition.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Article 4(6), PDF/printed pp. 9–10; Article 7 refugees; Article 16, p. 38.

Access note: Complete 39-page PDF acquired; selected provisions and corridor pages inspected.

Five minutes: Find pp. 9–10. What is assigned and what requires implementation?

Fifteen minutes: Read the corridor, relevant rights/refugee provision and Article 16 with the annexes.

geneva_corridor · Proposed arrangement

West Bank–Gaza Corridor, Annex 02

Geneva Initiative · Annex date not established; version checked 26 October 2026

Open original source

The annex separates Israeli sovereignty from Palestinian administration, assigns entrance/exit responsibility to the Palestinian state, and specifies opening/closure conditions. Palestinian courts have preferential, not exclusive, jurisdiction. The exact route remains for later determination.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Section 2: PDF p. 2/printed p. 82; section 3: PDF p. 3; section 6(3),(7): PDF p. 6/printed p. 86; finance: PDF p. 7.

Access note: Complete eight-page PDF acquired; sections 2, 3, 4 and 6–7 directly verified in the academic audit of 26 October 2026; the source’s AND is retained.

Five minutes: Compare entrance/exit allocation with the closure conditions. Which claim changes?

Fifteen minutes: Inspect the source’s combined conditions, then examine any explicitly labeled editorial alternative. Keep administration, law, route, security and finance separate.

geneva_ivg · Proposed arrangement

Implementation and Verification Group, Annex 01

Geneva Initiative · Annex date not established; version checked 26 October 2026

Open original source

The IVG military component has a corridor guarantee function and a specified negotiation/mediation pathway. Personnel, equipment, financing and decisions remain separate prerequisites. An assigned duty is not demonstrated operational capability.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Section 5(15)(d), PDF p. 12/printed p. 68; section 7, PDF p. 19/printed p. 75; finance/personnel sections 1–2.

Access note: Full annex acquired; relevant provisions inspected and key pages visually checked.

Five minutes: Who has the function, and who supplies capability?

Fifteen minutes: Trace the specified dispute pathway and its required agreements, decisions and resources.

geneva_map · Proposed map

Geneva 2003 Model for a Permanent Agreement — published map

Geneva Initiative map in Shaul Arieli’s collection · Identified as the Geneva 2003 model

Open original source

The actual published image supports bounded qualitative inspection of the proposal. Colors alone do not assign every power or determine precise corridor alignment.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Whole raster image, title and legend.

Access note: Image and collection title visually inspected; reproduction clearance separate.

Five minutes: Which question needs a map, and which a clause?

Fifteen minutes: Compare the map, corridor text and affected rights without substituting one for another.

alfa · Proposed arrangement

From Conflict to Reconciliation: A Land for All

A Land for All · Undated draft for discussion; acquired 26 October 2026

Open original source

The twenty-page brochure proposes two sovereign democratic states with shared institutions and distinct citizenship/residence. It discusses phased residence by consent, property redress, Gaza’s connection and an interstate rights court.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: PDF p. 3 tenets; pp. 6–7 return/property; pp. 8–9 residence; pp. 12–13 security; pp. 15–16 Gaza; pp. 17–18 institutions.

Access note: Complete twenty-page PDF acquired by direct download and read; earlier redirect failure superseded.

Five minutes: Compare citizenship, residence and property on pp. 6–9.

Fifteen minutes: Compare acquired institution/Gaza/security sections with Geneva under one criterion; leave unspecified details unknown.

odsc · Proposed arrangement

Programme for a multicultural democratic state in Palestine–Israel

One Democratic State Campaign · Programme April 2018; official posting 4 May 2019

Open original source

The programme proposes common constitutional citizenship, collective rights, newly constituted coercive institutions and return/property redress. Test these commitments and dependencies, rather than assuming a one-state label creates equality.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Programme points 1–4: citizenship, collective rights, coercive institutions and property/return.

Access note: Full official programme retrieved; relevant points inspected.

Five minutes: Apply the same property or participation question used for Geneva.

Fifteen minutes: Trace a promised right through authority, remedy and adoption; identify unestablished detail.

adalah_constitution · Proposed arrangement

The Democratic Constitution

Adalah — The Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel · Draft posted 20 March 2007

Open original source

The draft connects constitutional equality, citizenship, language and historical redress. Its actual rights propositions can challenge a test instrument’s assumptions rather than supply a generic democratic label.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Introduction pp. 4–5; citizenship clauses 15–16, pp. 7–8; bilingual state, clause 17.

Access note: Complete nineteen-page PDF acquired; relevant provisions inspected.

Five minutes: Does your criterion capture a proposed citizenship or language right?

Fifteen minutes: Compare a provision and explanatory notes with implementation and scope questions.

badil · Data / rights research

Survey of Palestinian refugees and internally displaced persons, 2019–2021 — brochure

BADIL Resource Center · Survey 2019–2021; brochure 2022

Open original source

The brochure identifies displaced people outside a resident map. Refugee/internal-displacement categories overlap other statuses and differ from citizenship, UNRWA registration or a proposed electorate.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Six-page brochure and worldwide-distribution map.

Access note: Complete brochure and map acquired and inspected; visual reuse separate.

Five minutes: Who disappears if only current West Bank residents are counted?

Fifteen minutes: Keep displacement, residence, citizenship and representation definitions separate.

taayush · Organization

Ta’ayush: declared purpose and field action

Ta’ayush · Undated self-description, checked 26 October 2026

Open original source

Ta’ayush describes joint Arab/Jewish, Palestinian/Israeli nonviolent action. Its archive covers only part of its work. A dated case record is needed to establish a particular action or effect.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: About/partnership, nonviolent action and archive-scope note.

Access note: Full self-description inspected and directly retrieved.

Five minutes: What can this actor do, and what power does it lack?

Fifteen minutes: Separate initiation, accompaniment, documentation and institutional response in a dated action.

rhr · Organization

Olive harvest accompaniment requested by Palestinian farmers

Rabbis for Human Rights · Undated page, checked 26 October 2026

Open original source

The organization describes responding to Palestinian farmers’ requests. The farmer’s project and initiative remain central; accompaniment is a task rather than sovereign protection.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Farmer requests and accompaniment role.

Access note: Full primary page inspected and directly retrieved.

Five minutes: Who requested the action and what was its task?

Fifteen minutes: Compare accompaniment with public duties, police power and enforceable remedy.

standing · Organization

Standing Together: dated organizing and solidarity actions

Standing Together · Checked 26 October 2026; selected actions dated 2024

Open original source

The movement describes Jewish-Palestinian organizing primarily within Israeli society and particular solidarity/aid actions. Separate a recorded action from a claim of durable effect or a whole population’s preference.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Dated aid/guard/solidarity actions and organizing context.

Access note: Full page and selected actions inspected and directly retrieved.

Five minutes: Identify initiative, date, action and limited result.

Fifteen minutes: Compare an action’s success with the durable protection a case needs.

cfp · Organization

Combatants for Peace: joint action and unequal power

Combatants for Peace · Undated self-description, checked 26 October 2026

Open original source

The joint movement describes co-resistance and unequal power. Former combatants founded it, but current membership is not limited to them. Its reconciliation framework is attributed, not a required learner conclusion.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Who We Are; co-resistance and asymmetric-power principles.

Access note: Full self-description inspected and directly retrieved.

Five minutes: Which action and authorization are distinct?

Fifteen minutes: Compare a dated action with adoption, review and enforcement powers.

bts · Organization

Breaking the Silence: military testimony and public education

Breaking the Silence · Undated page, checked 26 October 2026

Open original source

The organization collects military testimony and undertakes education aimed at ending occupation. A particular account can document a reported practice; it is not a representative Palestinian voice or a population rate.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Organization/about description.

Access note: Full organizational description inspected and directly retrieved.

Five minutes: What did this particular witness report, and when?

Fifteen minutes: Compare testimony, official rule and implementation without treating any as complete.

loc_workroom · Photographic record

Arab Women’s Union of Ramallah work rooms

American Colony Photo Department; Library of Congress record · Between 1934 and 1939

Open original source

The photograph records a productive institution and work setting. It permits an ordinary-life inquiry without making later harm the only reason people appear. Preserve the external photographer’s position and actual date range.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Item 2019708549; matpc.17779; caption, date and rights advisory.

Access note: Catalogue and rights advisory inspected.

Five minutes: What does the picture show, and what needs another record?

Fifteen minutes: Compare catalogue and Palestinian Museum research on production, class and representation.

nrc_movement · Legal analysis

Movement between the West Bank and Gaza: legal memorandum

Norwegian Refugee Council · December 2016

Open original source

The legal memorandum traces changing movement instruments: the general-exit framework, its suspension, individual permission and general closure. The chronology precedes the delegated Palestinian institutions established through Oslo.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: PDF pages 1–2: 1967 closure orders, 1972 general exit permission, 1988 revocation, 1991 individual permits and March 1993 closure; footnotes identify the original instruments.

Access note: Complete nine-page PDF directly retrieved in the academic audit on 26 October 2026; publication date and historical sequence checked. Original military orders remain separate sources.

Five minutes: Compare the 1972, 1988, 1991 and 1993 changes. Which instrument changed the stated permission?

Fifteen minutes: Follow one change through the memorandum and its footnotes. Separate the historical permission, implementation and any causal explanation.

oslo_ii · Agreement

Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and Gaza Strip

Israel and Palestine Liberation Organization; UN document record · 28 September 1995

Open original source

The interim agreement distinguishes transferred functions from residual powers and jurisdictional exclusions. Administering a service is not the same question as controlling every condition required to provide it.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Articles I and XVII (printed pages 3 and 13–14): transferred functions and retained or excluded powers; Annex III, Appendix 1, Article 9 (printed page 110): education; Article 27 (printed pages 126–127): planning and zoning; Article 28 (printed pages 127–128): population registry. PDF and printed page numbers align in this copy.

Access note: Complete 188-page original agreement copy, including annexes, directly retrieved on 26 October 2026. Articles I/XVII and relevant education, planning and registry provisions inspected. This replaces the earlier UN-page 403 intake limit; it does not establish implementation.

Five minutes: Compare Article XVII with Annex III, Article 9. Does responsibility for schools establish authority over every condition of a school journey?

Fifteen minutes: Compare education with the planning and registry provisions. Identify the institution, geographical scope, condition and missing implementation evidence for one power.

sabbagh_khoury · Academic argument

The Internally Displaced Palestinians in Israel, in The Palestinians in Israel: Readings in History, Politics and Society

Areej Sabbagh-Khoury; Mada al-Carmel · 2011

Open original source

The chapter distinguishes citizenship, internal displacement and the relationship to a home or property. Palestinian citizens of Israel and occupied noncitizens occupy different legal positions; citizenship does not erase displacement or automatically restore property.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Printed pp. 27–31, especially opening definitions on pp. 27–28; consult volume contents for the full chapter.

Access note: 137-page volume retrieved. Editors' introduction, chapter opening, definitions, and historical examples inspected. The chapter is available in full. This is the usable full-text source; the related 2015 Rouhana/Sabbagh-Khoury article returned 403, and the 2022 Sabbagh-Khoury article was available only as an abstract/references.

Five minutes: Identify one specific claim the record supports and one question it leaves open.

Fifteen minutes: Compare its date, evidence and institutional scope with the case. Keep reported facts, interpretation and unresolved questions separate.

akevot · Archival record

File GL-17005/6: reordering control at the end of military government

Akevot Institute · Dated source; see original

Open original source

The archival presentation opens an original-document route into the late stages of military government over Palestinian citizens of Israel. Ending a named institution and ending every practice of control are distinct historical propositions.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: File GL-17005/6; documents and editorial presentation on the 1963–1969 transition.

Access note: Saved review and direct audit record the primary archival presentation as retrieved.

Five minutes: Identify one specific claim the record supports and one question it leaves open.

Fifteen minutes: Compare its date, evidence and institutional scope with the case. Keep reported facts, interpretation and unresolved questions separate.

arieli · Geographical argument

The Collapse of the Two-State Solution Is a Political Decision, Not a Geographic or Economic One

Shaul Arieli · February 2026

Open original source

Arieli argues that political choices, rather than an unavoidable spatial barrier, obstruct partition. His specified comparison reports 77% of West Bank settlers within ten kilometers of the Green Line in 2015 and 2025, treating East Jerusalem separately.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Four-page essay; concentration claim and geographical/economic argument.

Access note: Full PDF acquired and inspected in the saved research; retained direct audit records a four-page text PDF.

Five minutes: Identify one specific claim the record supports and one question it leaves open.

Fifteen minutes: Compare its date, evidence and institutional scope with the case. Keep reported facts, interpretation and unresolved questions separate.

gaza_service_photo · Photographic record

Khan Yunis wastewater-treatment facility: historical photograph

Muhammad Sabah / B’Tselem · 4 February 2014

Open original source

The photograph depicts the Khan Yunis Water Authority wastewater-treatment facility on 4 February 2014. It makes infrastructure visible; the photograph is not a current operating report.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Individual Commons record, original caption and license.

Access note: Saved image record and original upload identified; reproduction is bounded by its caption and CC BY 4.0 attribution.

Five minutes: Identify one specific claim the record supports and one question it leaves open.

Fifteen minutes: Compare its date, evidence and institutional scope with the case. Keep reported facts, interpretation and unresolved questions separate.

labour_love · Museum interpretation

Labour of Love: New Approaches to Palestinian Embroidery

The Palestinian Museum · Dated source; see original

Open original source

The museum guide provides a researched route into Palestinian embroidery, production and representation. Ordinary labor and culture deserve attention beyond their appearance as background to a later harm.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Thirteen-page exhibition guide; identify the relevant object and section before using it.

Access note: Saved research and direct audit record acquisition of the 13-page guide.

Five minutes: Identify one specific claim the record supports and one question it leaves open.

Fifteen minutes: Compare its date, evidence and institutional scope with the case. Keep reported facts, interpretation and unresolved questions separate.

gordon · Academic argument

From Colonization to Separation: Exploring the Structure of Israel’s Occupation

Neve Gordon · Dated source; see original

Open original source

Gordon’s author-page extract offers an interpretation of institutional reorganization: changing relationships to the population alongside retained control of resources. It is a competing explanation to examine with dated evidence.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Author-page extract; linked full article is a separate resource.

Access note: Author-page extract read in retained research; full linked article was unavailable.

Five minutes: Identify one specific claim the record supports and one question it leaves open.

Fifteen minutes: Compare its date, evidence and institutional scope with the case. Keep reported facts, interpretation and unresolved questions separate.

poster_landday · Archival lead

Land Day poster record using Mona Saudi’s artwork

Palestinian Museum collection; artwork attributed to Mona Saudi · Dated source; see original

Open original source

A source lead for examining a political poster as an authored proposition: identify producer, audience, date and the future it advocates before drawing a conclusion.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Collection item; verify object metadata and reproduction permission at the original.

Access note: Archival lead retained; direct audit returned HTTP 307. No poster image is bundled on this authority alone.

Five minutes: Identify one specific claim the record supports and one question it leaves open.

Fifteen minutes: Compare its date, evidence and institutional scope with the case. Keep reported facts, interpretation and unresolved questions separate.

poster_peacenow · Archival lead

Peace Now poster and sign archive record

National Library of Israel · Dated source; see original

Open original source

This archive lead can support inquiry into the language and audience of a particular peace-movement proposition, once the individual object and metadata have been inspected.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Archive record AL997013034414005171.

Access note: Identified lead in saved design/research packet; not represented as an acquired game image.

Five minutes: Identify one specific claim the record supports and one question it leaves open.

Fifteen minutes: Compare its date, evidence and institutional scope with the case. Keep reported facts, interpretation and unresolved questions separate.

poster_disengagement · Archival lead

Anti-disengagement march archive material

National Library of Israel · Dated source; see original

Open original source

The record offers a route to inspect opposition to disengagement as an authored political claim. A poster or march image is evidence of advocacy, not a proof that the advocated claim is true.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Archive record AL997013035075905171.

Access note: Identified source lead in saved packet; no invented facsimile or clearance.

Five minutes: Identify one specific claim the record supports and one question it leaves open.

Fifteen minutes: Compare its date, evidence and institutional scope with the case. Keep reported facts, interpretation and unresolved questions separate.

ocha_disengagement · Contemporaneous record

What changed during the 2005 disengagement?

UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) · 12 September 2005; companion report 23 August 2005

Open original source

OCHA recorded free traffic at Gaza’s Abu Houli junction and access to former enclaves after checkpoints and fences were dismantled. Some roads still needed repairs; external crossings had distinct conditions. The separate August northern West Bank report records evacuations alongside continued restrictions, not a general reopening.

What it supports

Limits

Where to look: Gaza report section 3, Internal movements and closure; compare section 2, External movements. Northern West Bank report sections 1, 4 and 5.

Access note: Both original PDFs acquired and text inspected.

Five minutes: Compare one connection already open with one awaiting repair. Why do they need different map states?

Fifteen minutes: Compare internal movement, external crossings and the northern West Bank report. Identify the gain, its place/date and limit.